For Valentine’s Day, do you want a night of romance or stale conversation?
A good Valentine’s Day gift can lead to a night of romance, but a bad one bought at the last minute can do just the opposite. Before you know it, the aisles have been picked clean and all that’s left is generic assortments that don’t say anything but “I forgot to shop before February 13th”. The ideal Valentine’s Day gift for the woman in your life isn’t picked up at the last second, but reflects everything you’ve learned about her over the last year.
Every woman is a little different, and that means every perfect gift will be a little different. Does she like intense dark chocolate, or sweet and indulgent milk chocolate? Is she going straight to Instagram to post an eye-catching gift? Does she get excited about Champagne or would she rather have strawberries? You already know these answers — you just need gift options that match them. In this article, we'll walk through 10 Valentine's gift basket options and help you figure out which one actually fits who she is.
The Best Valentine’s Day Gifts Begin With Paying Attention
We all have different tastes and preferences, so there’s no such thing as a one-size-fits-all solution for gifts - no matter how much easier that would make shopping! To find the perfect Valentine’s Day present for your Valentine this year, it’s best to start preparing early by observing her and figuring out exactly what she loves in a gift.
Finding out that she has a sweet tooth is a good start, but with so many options, it’s even better if you know if she prefers chocolate, fruit, pastries, or something else entirely. Knowing her style will make it easier to determine which gift basket looks like the perfect fit for her. Does she like to keep things relaxed and comfy, or is she always at the top of her game and dressed to impress? Which love languages communicate care best to her? Is she the kind of person who would melt over a written declaration of love, an unforgettable experience, a meaningful gift, or a combination of all love expressions?
Classic Romantic Valentine’s Baskets
These two gift baskets are an ideal pick if the special woman in your life enjoys classic gifts. Both are built around one of the most iconic Valentine’s Day treats of all time: chocolate-covered strawberries. A perfect choice for sharing on a romantic night together, if you ask us.
All My Love Berries ($59.99)
All My Love Berries is our most colorful assortment of chocolate-covered strawberries. We take a dozen fresh, hand-picked strawberries, cover them in Belgian chocolate, then finish them with an eye-catching assortment of sprinkles, candy hearts, and drizzles of pink and white chocolate.
Who it's best for: This is the perfect fit for a woman who eats, lives, and breathes Valentine’s Day. It’s hard to imagine a gift that looks more like a fitting treat for the day, and it’s perfect if she wants to post an eye-catching image of her gift before digging into it.
Skip this if: This is the quintessential Valentine’s Day treat in all its colorful, over-the-top glory, so if she’s the kind who rolls her eyes at pink-and-red displays in February, keep on looking.
Dark Chocolate Covered Strawberries Dozen ($54.99)
Dark Chocolate Covered Strawberries Dozen is our simple, classic option. We take twelve oversized strawberries and hand-dip them in rich Belgian dark chocolate. We finish them with delicate drizzles of melted chocolate, creating distinctive patterns.
Who it's best for: If you know she enjoys dark chocolate and strawberries, this gift could be the perfect fit. The presentation is tasteful and simple, the taste is rich and flavorful, and the whole package is perfect for a romantic night together.
Skip this if: You’re not sure if she loves dark chocolate or strawberries, or if she prefers her treats a little more over-the-top.
Luxury & Elegant Valentine’s Baskets
Does your valentine have a taste for the finer things in life? We’ve got you covered with these two gift baskets. Even though they both feature a taste of French luxury, they couldn’t be more different. One is an all-out spread of some of our highest-end products, perfect for a truly unforgettable night. The other is a beautiful display of some of the most delicate and delicious pastries, at a price that suits any budget.
Champagne & Truffles Gift Basket - Dom Perignon ($699.99)
Champagne & Truffles Gift Basket - Dom Pérignon features Dom Perignon champagne paired with a decadent mix of chocolate chip cookies, mudpuppies, French vanilla malted milk balls, chocolate caramels, chocolate caramel grahams, and sparkling prosecco cordials.
Who it's best for: This is the ideal package for anyone celebrating a major relationship milestone. It’s an assortment that begs to be shared slowly over a fancy night together, perfect for big anniversaries, engagements, or other once-in-a-lifetime Valentine’s Days. If she has a taste for the finer things in life, the Dom Pérignon will send the right message.
Skip this if: Champagne isn’t her thing, or if you’re looking for a more casual Valentine’s Day experience.
Valentine's Day Macarons ($39.99)
Valentine's Day Macarons bundle features ten handcrafted French macarons in multiple flavors, made with fresh, premium ingredients. These delicious treats are gluten-free.
Who it's best for: This is ideal for a woman with a taste for French pastries and a love of the finer things in life. Macarons are delicate and elegant, making eating them feel like a special event while not overwhelming you with sweetness.. The fact they're naturally gluten-free (almond flour base) makes this a perfect choice for anyone with food intolerances without sacrificing decadence.
Skip this if: She's not familiar with macarons or prefers more traditional American desserts like chocolates or candy. These can be an acquired taste due to their crispy, light texture.
Valentine’s Baskets for Chocolate & Dessert Lovers
There’s no more iconic Valentine’s Day treat than chocolate, and it’s front and center in these three gift baskets. The finest Belgian chocolate serves as a cloak for a variety of treats, ranging from sweet and nostalgic desserts to a sweet-and-savory assortment perfect for grownups.
Love Oreo® Cookies ($44.99)
Love Oreo® Cookies features twelve Oreo cookies hand-dipped in Belgian chocolate (milk, dark, and white chocolate varieties), with four decorated with "LOVE" spelled out in white chocolate lettering. The remaining eight are finished with swirls of red and white icing and sprinkles.
Who it's best for: This is perfect for a woman who loves sweets and is easily won over by elevated nostalgia. It’s a fun, casual gift that won’t feel overwhelming or intimidating, and also works well as an accompaniment for a different gift or night out. If you want to spend some time sharing treats, this is a perfect choice.
Skip this if: he's not an Oreo fan or prefers desserts that are more chocolate-forward.
All My Love Cheesecake Bites ($64.99)
The All My Love Cheesecake Bites gift is a sure choice for the woman you cherish if she’s a fan of cheesecake. These cheesecake bites are hand-dipped in Belgian chocolate and carefully decorated in Valentine’s Day colors.
Who it's best for: Cheesecake fans who want the flavor they love without a full cake. These desserts are incredibly rich and creamy under the chocolate layer, so they are ideal for anyone who wants an indulgent dessert. These bites should last a few days when refrigerated, so they’re perfect for keeping the Valentine’s Day fun going a little longer.
Skip this if: She’s not a big fan of chocolate, prefers a specific type of chocolate, or prefers understated Valentine’s Day vibes rather than going all-in on the hearts.
Valentine's Day Belgian Chocolate Gift Box ($64.99)
Valentine's Day Belgian Chocolate Gift Box offering is our most classic assortment, the perfect choice for a true chocoholic. The bundle features Belgian chocolate-dipped cookies, pretzels, and assorted treats. The decorations are classy but playful, with a classic red-and-pink vibe.
Who it's best for: A lady who loves chocolate is unlikely to keep it a secret. That’s one of the easier tastes to shop for, but we’re offering an arrangement that’s a cut above the rest..
Skip this if: She’s not a big fan of chocolate, prefers a specific type of chocolate, or prefers understated Valentine’s Day vibes rather than going all-in on the hearts.
Fun & Casual Valentine’s Baskets
Are you shopping for a high-school sweetheart - or is your Valentine still a kid at heart? This next assortment of gift baskets may be the perfect fit. These budget-friendly options lean heavily into sweet treats, with a mix of chocolate and fruity candies. You’ll find some of the most famous Valentine’s brands here - or you can go a different route with an assortment of fresh-baked delights.
Deluxe With Love Care Package ($59.99)
Deluxe With Love Care Package features classic, nostalgic theater box candies including Hot Tamales, Mike and Ike, Sugar Babies, plus Valentine's Day cinnamon and brown sugar kettle corn.
Who it's best for: If she prefers candy over chocolate and has a taste for nostalgic theater candies, this package would be perfect. It’s lighthearted and cute while still showing you know her tastes, and it’s a great budget-friendly option.
Skip this if: She prefers chocolate over fruit and cinnamon flavors, or you want a gift that shows deeper feelings than a casual candy assortment.
Filled With Love Popcorn And Candy ($39.99)
Filled With Love Popcorn And Candy includes cinnamon and brown sugar kettle corn and an assortment of Valentine's Day-themed candies including fruit and chocolate, in a box designed like a care package.
Who it's best for: Newer relationships, casual Valentine's exchanges, or when you want something fun and shareable without any pressure. The cinnamon brown sugar kettle corn has a nice, subtle sweetness without being overwhelming. Also works as an add-on to another gift.
Skip this if: She’s not a big snacker, or you’re looking for something less casual that sends a more romantic message.
With Love Cookie & Brownie Gift Box ($39.99)
With Love Cookie & Brownie Gift Box includes four indulgent brownie and cookie types packaged in a pink box with hearts all over it.
Who it's best for: A Valentine who wouldn’t want you to go overboard, either because this is a new relationship or because they prefer to keep things casual and playful. It’s thoughtful, fun, and budget-friendly, but still shows you care.
Skip this if: It will feel generic to her. This kind of gift is best for early on in a relationship or as a more casual expression of care.
Quick Tips to Pick the Right Valentine’s Day Gift for Her
You probably know by now which gifts you’re leaning toward. If you need to filter it down to a final choice, consider these factors:
How to choose a gift basket by stage of the relationship
Every Valentine’s gift comes with its own set of circumstances, because no relationship is the same. One of the best guideposts is how long you’ve been with your Valentine. A first Valentine’s Day together requires a very different strategy than a long, lived-in relationship. No matter how long you’ve been together, go with what feels like a match and doesn’t stress your wallet.
Some quick guidelines by relationship length:
-
Under six months together: Try to stick to $39-$60 so that the gift is thoughtful, but doesn’t come off as overly intense.
-
Six months to a year: This relationship stage is good for the $54-$99 range. A gift at this tier will demonstrate your investment without overdoing it.
-
Over a year: When you’ve been together over a year, you should have a sense of what’s appropriate and desired for your financial circumstances. Anywhere from $54 to $699 can work for this relationship stage, depending on her traits and your shared values.
How to choose based on the type of experience you want to create
-
A memorable and romantic dinner at home: Strawberries and champagne work well for an experience like this one.
-
A surprise on Valentine’s Day morning: Chocolate boxes, macarons, or anything else that can be paired with coffee would be perfect for this vision.
-
A long-distance gesture: You want a gift package that will communicate your feelings from afar, and can also withstand the shipping experience and arrive in tip-top condition. One of our Fun & Casual Gift Baskets might be an ideal fit, especially the neatly-packed care package.
-
A low-key celebration: Our popcorn and candy baskets make the perfect accompaniment for a night in.
How long should the gift last?
The only one of our baskets that has a shorter shelf-life is our chocolate-covered strawberries. These should be enjoyed within a few days, ideally the day it arrives. Baked goods, especially those covered in chocolate, can last for weeks. Candy won’t expire for months, and wine can be enjoyed indefinitely.
Is this a gift she would choose for herself?
Does she love chocolate? Does she love baked goods? Is popcorn her choice? We can’t answer this one for you, but observe her snack choices to select the right gift!
Is this gift aligned with how she likes to celebrate Valentine’s Day?
Not all women prefer romantic displays. Some of our gifts are more suited to a casual celebration, while others are ideal for an intimate and memorable night together.
Does the idea of giving this to her make you feel excited?
We can’t answer this one either, but if you’ve made it this far in the article, you’re on the right track. A great Valentine’s Day gift is one enjoyed together. Visualize how the gift you’re considering will make her feel, and how she’ll react. If you can already see your perfect Valentine’s Day unfolding the second she opens her basket, you might have found the perfect pick.
Final Thoughts
If she’s talked about how she can’t wait to visit authentic French patisseries, the Valentine's Day Macarons show you’re paying attention to her tastes. If she always orders dark chocolate desserts, the Dark Chocolate Strawberries hit a real preference, not a guess.
The best gift is the one where she opens it and thinks, "he gets me.” Start with what you know she actually enjoys, match it to a gift basket that delivers, and you're set. Order by February 7th for guaranteed Valentine's Day delivery, and you'll have one less thing to worry about.